Martin Plaut and the Question of Selective Outrage

You can listen to the audio of this article.
Excerpt
An urgent appeal amplified by veteran journalist Martin Plaut over alleged Amhara killings in Wallagga raises questions extending beyond the atrocity itself. While every civilian death demands condemnation, investigation and justice, documented Amhara Fano violence against Oromo communities in the same region has received markedly different attention. This article examines that asymmetry, the missing context, and a fundamental journalistic principle: no community should be dispossessed of its suffering—or even of its cry for justice.
1. When Outrage Becomes Selective
An appeal circulated by veteran journalist and Horn of Africa commentator Martin Plaut caught our attention for the gravest of reasons. Published on 29 August 2026 under the title “Ethiopia: An urgent appeal for action following Amhara deaths” [1], it concerns allegations of horrific killings of Amhara civilians in Wallagga, Oromia. The accompanying material includes deeply disturbing images and allegations of killings, displacement, destruction of homes and churches, and participation by regional security forces.
Let us begin where any discussion of such allegations must begin: the murder of civilians is indefensible, irrespective of the identity of the victims or perpetrators.
If Amhara civilians have been murdered, their deaths must be investigated. Those responsible must be identified and prosecuted. The ethnicity of the victims neither increases nor diminishes their right to justice.
Our concern is therefore not that Martin Plaut has drawn attention to alleged atrocities against Amhara civilians.
Our concern is whether he applies the same journalistic urgency, skepticism and visibility when the civilians being killed in precisely the same part of Ethiopia are Oromo.
That question is unavoidable.
2. What Happened to the Other Wallagga?
Only weeks before Plaut amplified this appeal, western Oromia was already experiencing another surge of violence attributed to armed Fano formations.
Reports on 12 August alleged that more than 30 civilians had been killed in an attack in Gida Ayana district, East Wallagga, attributed by eyewitnesses to Fano forces [2]. More violence followed.
The situation became serious enough that between 19 and 21 August residents of Gida Ayana and Angar Guttee, together with Oromo students at Wallagga University, reportedly demonstrated demanding government action against Fano attacks.
This is not merely an allegation circulating within Oromo political media [3].
Conflict-monitoring organization ACLED reports that Fano activity in western Oromia has expanded substantially. According to ACLED, the activities of Fano militias in Horo Guduru, Kellem, East and West Wallagga increased by approximately 80 percent between 1 January and 21 August 2026 compared with the corresponding period in 2025.
ACLED further attributes the 19 August Tulu Lencha ambush to the "Wallagga Fano" so called "Bizamo Command" [4]. Among those reportedly killed were passengers, a patient traveling in an ambulance, a midwife and three bank managers, as well as soldiers.
These are not peripheral details.
They establish that Fano is itself an armed actor operating inside Wallagga and must therefore form part of any serious investigation into the violence there.
3. Plaut’s Own Pages Make the Question Harder to Avoid
There is an extraordinary additional detail.
Martin Plaut himself published an interview with Fano leader Zemene Kassie on 16 August [5]. In that interview, Kassie described Fano's expanding organization and explicitly referred to forces operating “around Wallaga.” He went on to claim that these formations had been brought together under a unified movement and command.
ACLED subsequently reported that the Wallagga Fano "Bizamo Command" is linked to the Amhara Fano National Movement (AFNM) and that the AFNM had claimed that the Bizamo Command now falls under its command.
This creates an obvious journalistic question.
If Plaut considered the organization and leadership of Fano sufficiently important to publish interviews and reports concerning its leadership, why does an appeal alleging mass atrocities in Wallagga not seriously examine Fano's presence, operations and possible role in the cycle of violence occurring in exactly the same territory?
That omission deserves explanation.
4. An Appeal Is Not an Investigation
There is another distinction readers should notice.
Plaut's 29 August publication [1] is not itself an independently established investigation of the alleged atrocities. It republishes an appeal signed simply by “Concerned Citizens of Ethiopia.”
The appeal claims that more than 400 Amhara civilians have been killed, more than 300 homes destroyed and approximately 15,000 people displaced. It alleges involvement by Oromia regional security forces and calls upon international genocide-prevention organizations to investigate whether genocide, crimes against humanity or other international crimes may have occurred.
These allegations are mirrored by grave claims from the Oromo side, although on a considerably larger scale and over a much longer period. For several years, Oromo communities in Wallagga have reported killings, mass displacement, dispossession of homes and farmland, the seizure of harvests, and the systematic looting of livestock allegedly driven across the border into the Amhara region. Many of these episodes have been accompanied by gruesome images of murdered civilians and scenes of mass flight. The allegations are therefore not simply competing accounts of a single incident, but part of a prolonged and bitterly contested record of violence, territorial encroachment and dispossession that cannot responsibly be excluded from the present discussion.
Those are extremely serious allegations.
They may prove true, partly true, exaggerated, misattributed or embedded within a far more complicated sequence of armed confrontation and retaliatory violence.
That is precisely why journalism matters.
The duty of an experienced foreign journalist should not end with transmitting an advocacy document. It should begin there.
- Who supplied the casualty figures?
- How were the victims identified?
- Where precisely did the killings occur?
- Over what period?
- Who controlled those locations?
- Which armed formations were present?
- What fighting preceded the killings?
- What role was played by regional security forces?
- What role was played by the OLA?
- What role was played by Amhara Fano formations already documented as operating in the area?
- And what role, if any, did the ENDF play?
Those questions do not diminish a single Amhara victim.
They are what taking those victims seriously requires.
5. The Missing Context Is Enormous
Violence attributed to Amhara Fano in Wallagga did not suddenly become an issue in August 2026.
Reports of Oromo civilians being killed and displaced by armed groups identified locally as Amhara Fano go back years. Addis Standard reported in December 2022 [6] that dozens of people had been killed in Kiremu district in attacks residents attributed to Amhara Fano militants. The district authorities said Oromo residents of 19 rural villages had been displaced.
More recent analysis describes the same theater of conflict as one in which armed Amhara Fano formations have entrenched themselves and expanded their activities.
This history matters because an atrocity cannot responsibly be analyzed after amputating everything that happened immediately before it.
If one community is attacked, displaced and dispossessed; armed actors move into contested territory; retaliatory forces mobilize; state security forces intervene; civilians belonging to another community are subsequently massacred; and the final episode alone is extracted from that chain and internationally presented as evidence of genocide, the resulting narrative may be emotionally powerful while remaining analytically incomplete.
The answer is not to suppress the second atrocity.
It is to investigate the whole chain.
6. ጩኸቴን ቀሙኝ — “They Even Took Away My Cry”
There is an Ethiopian expression that captures something deeper than physical dispossession:
ጩኸቴን ቀሙኝ — “They even took away my cry.”
It describes the final indignity: suffering an injustice and then discovering that even the language of victimhood has been taken from you.
For many Oromos, that expression has acquired an uncomfortable contemporary relevance.
The allegation repeatedly made by Oromo activists is not merely that Oromo suffering receives insufficient international attention. It is that violence occurring against Oromo communities is sometimes removed from the narrative, while subsequent violence involving Amhara victims is presented internationally without the preceding context—or, in the most serious allegation, with victim and aggressor effectively reversed.
That allegation itself must be subjected to evidence.
But so must the narratives it challenges.
No ethnic constituency should possess a monopoly over victimhood, and no armed movement should acquire immunity from scrutiny merely because the community from which it draws support has itself suffered terrible atrocities.
Amhara civilians can be victims of atrocity.
Oromo civilians can be victims of atrocity.
Amhara Fano can fight the Ethiopian government and simultaneously be accused of atrocities against civilians.
The OLA can claim to defend Oromo interests and simultaneously be investigated for crimes against civilians.
Government forces can claim to protect communities while themselves committing grave abuses.
None of these propositions cancels another.
That is precisely why selective narratives are so dangerous.
7. The Question for Martin Plaut
We therefore put the matter carefully.
We are not asserting as established fact that Martin Plaut deliberately suppresses Oromo suffering or knowingly promotes an Amhara political narrative. Such a conclusion would require substantially more evidence.
We are saying something narrower, but serious enough:
his recent coverage raises a legitimate question of editorial asymmetry that deserves scrutiny.
When allegations concerning more than 400 Amhara deaths are presented to an international audience, the response is an urgent appeal invoking genocide and atrocity prevention.
- Where was comparable urgency when Oromo civilians were reportedly being killed in the same Wallagga theater by armed Amhara Fano formations?
- Where was the examination of the territorial dimension of Amhara Fano's presence in western Oromia?
- Where was the international appeal when Oromo communities were reporting killings, displacement and loss of property?
And, most importantly, why does an appeal concerning atrocities in Wallagga receive amplification without placing prominently before readers the documented fact that an organized Amhara Fano military formation is itself operating there?
These questions become even more compelling because Plaut's own website has carried material concerning Amhara Fano's organization and leadership.
8. Condemn the Crime — Investigate the Narrative
The photograph of a murdered woman does not become less horrifying because Oromo civilians were murdered elsewhere.
Nor does the murder of Oromo civilians become less important because Amhara civilians have subsequently been killed.
The ethical standard must work in both directions.
- Investigate the killing of Amhara civilians.
- Investigate the killing of Oromo civilians.
- Investigate the Oromia regional forces.
- Investigate the OLA.
- Investigate the ENDF.
And investigate the Fano formations operating inside Wallagga—including their command structures, territorial objectives, sources of support, civilian conduct and relationship with the wider Amhara Fano movement.
Then reconstruct the chronology.
- Who attacked whom?
- Where?
- When?
- Who occupied which territory?
- Who displaced whom?
- Who returned?
- Who retaliated?
- Who benefited?
Only after those questions have been answered should anyone casually reach for the most consequential word in the vocabulary of international crimes: genocide.
The dead deserve considerably more than competing ethnic press releases.
They deserve the truth.
And journalists—especially internationally recognised journalists whose reputations give enormous amplification to claims emerging from Ethiopia's information war—have a particular responsibility to ensure that one people's cry is not amplified by silencing another's.
References
- Ethiopia: An urgent appeal for action following Amhara civilian deaths in Oromia, 29 August 2026, Martin Plaut's X Page, X Inc.
- Massacre in East Wollega: Over 30 Civilians Killed in Fano Attack, 12 August 2026, Oromedia.
- OT Editorial, What the PP Regime Achieved for the Oromo People and Oromia: Part I — The Positive Achievements, 16 August 2026, OROMIA TODAY.
- Dr. Jalale Getachew Birru, Is Fano militias’ activity increasing in the western part of Ethiopia’s Oromia region?, 28 August 2026, ACLED.
- ETHIOPIA — Zemene Kassie, leader of the Fano militia, announces the creation of a unified command and alliances with several organizations, including Tigray. Objective: overthrow Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed, 16 August 2026, martinplaut.com website.
- News: District court judge, dozens of civilians killed, entire residents of a district displaced in attacks blamed on “Fano militants” in East Wollega, 3 December 2022, Addis Standard.






