Related Posts

One Comment

  1. This is a powerful piece, and it names something too often obscured by procedural language: what’s at stake in this “national dialogue” is not administrative tidiness but the single constitutional thread — Article 39’s recognition of nations’ self-determination and Article 49’s framing of Finfinnee’s relationship to Oromia — that has held Ethiopia’s diverse nations and nationalities together within one state. Cut that thread, and what’s offered as reconciliation becomes its opposite.

    The article’s reframing is essential: this isn’t a debate about federal cities versus autonomous regions. It’s a question of whether historical dispossession can be quietly ratified by relabeling it. The “imagine it happened elsewhere” thought experiment makes this vivid — success built on conquest doesn’t make the conquest legitimate, it just makes it harder to see.

    Equally important is what the piece refuses to do: it doesn’t ask today’s Finfinnee residents to answer for Menelik’s conquests, and it doesn’t treat decolonization as eviction. Recognition, restitution, and reconciliation — the article’s own framework — leaves room for a cosmopolitan Finfinnee that is also, honestly, an Oromo city.

    The deeper danger is procedural, not just territorial: a dialogue commission assembled without the mandate to touch Article 39 and 49 in the first place is positioning itself to unravel the very accommodation that makes a multinational Ethiopia possible — under the banner of dialogue rather than through it.

    The timing compounds the illegitimacy. A government currently waging war against three regional states home to some 70 percent of the country’s population, with over 30 million people in need of food aid, has neither the moral standing nor the practical bandwidth to convene a credible national conversation on constitutional first principles. A state in that condition should be addressing the crises it has created, not assembling a sham dialogue to strip Oromia of its constitutional rights.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

3 + 11 =