Related Posts

One Comment

  1. Berlin, 1884, did not ask whether Africa’s peoples had the right to govern themselves. That question was foreclosed before the delegates sat down; what remained was the technical work of apportionment — which power would take which territory, along which rivers and parallels. The people whose land was being divided were not present, and their absence was not an oversight. It was the precondition. No conference that had to negotiate with the peoples of a continent, rather than merely about them, could have partitioned it in fourteen weeks.

    The Ethiopian National Dialogue reproduces this structure with uncomfortable precision. It is not a body asking whether Article 39 and Article 49 should exist, whether multinational federalism reflects a just settlement, or whether Oromia’s claim to Finfinnee carries constitutional weight. Those questions have already been decided by the act of exclusion. The Oromo political organizations that have carried the argument for self-determination for a generation are not seated at the table where Oromia’s own capital is being discussed. That is not incidental — it is the mechanism. Berlin required the absence of African polities to do its work of division; the ENDC requires the absence of the OLF, the OFC, and other Oromo political forces to do its work of dismantlement. A conference cannot partition what its rightful claimants are present to defend.

    What made Africa available for division was its prior designation as terra nullius — land without sovereign owners, however densely inhabited, however old its kingdoms. The Ethiopian dialogue performs the same act on constitutional rather than geographic ground. Article 39 and Article 49 are treated as provisional arrangements awaiting a more permanent settlement, rather than what they are: the negotiated terms under which nations and nationalities agreed to remain within a common state. To place those articles on the table in a dialogue Oromo political forces are barred from attending is to declare, in constitutional language, that the ground beneath Oromo self-determination is unowned — available for reapportionment by others.

    Berlin was never called conquest. It was called order — the responsible management of a chaotic space by parties capable of administering it properly. Chairman Mesfin’s insistence on an “Ethiopia-centered” middle borrows this same vocabulary. It asks Oromo participants, and others carrying comparable histories, to treat their claims as the disorder requiring management, and “Ethiopia” — undefined, unexamined, assumed rather than argued for — as the administering principle that resolves it. But Oromia is not a frontier awaiting administration. It is the constitutional home of a people who fought for and secured the right to determine their own affairs. A dialogue that treats that right as negotiable, while declining to seat the organizations that would defend it, is not administering order. It is redrawing a map.

    Nor is it accidental which territory sits at the center of this redrawing. Oromia is the empire’s breadbasket, its labor, its land, and — in Finfinnee — its former seat, and it remains the nostalgic home of those who profited from the centralized state the federal constitution was built to supersede. A dialogue capable of loosening Oromia’s federal protections and unsettling Finfinnee’s constitutional status is not a technical exercise in reconciliation. It is the restoration of precisely what the 1991 settlement was designed to end. That the dialogue’s institutional energy gathers so persistently around the federal arrangement and the status of the capital is not incidental — it is the structure’s purpose, expressed in the language of convergence rather than conquest, as Berlin expressed partition in the language of civilization.

    Berlin’s delegates did not need to hate the peoples whose land they divided; many believed sincerely they were bringing order to chaos. The harm never depended on malice. It depended on a process that filtered out the one perspective that could have corrected it, and replaced it with the shared assumptions of those doing the dividing. The ENDC’s funnel — from four thousand participants down through successive rounds of consolidation — performs the same filtering on constitutional argument that Berlin performed on territorial claims. A sharply stated case for Article 39 as non-negotiable does not need to be shouted down to disappear. It only needs to pass through enough rounds of a process instructed to seek the Ethiopia-centered middle, among a body from which its most committed defenders were excluded from the start, for its edges to be sanded away by delegates who never held them in the first place.

    The remedy Berlin never offered its victims — a seat at the table where their future was being decided — is precisely what the ENDC withholds from Oromo political forces today. Until that seat exists, the dialogue is not adjudicating Oromia’s constitutional status. It is settling it in Oromia’s absence, and calling the settlement consensus.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

20 − five =